I bought the book Hillbilly Elegy when it was first released at the urging of a couple colleagues of mine at the time back in 2016 when I was working for a philanthropic advising firm in San Francisco. I recall getting about 2 chapters in and for some reason or another losing interest. It wasn’t until about 2 weeks ago, on a long-awaited and deserved break (if I do say so myself) from my duties as an educator at a University here in NC that I eagerly picked it back up. I’d like to say that I don’t know what it was that made me devour this book now and yet not be able to even get through a couple chapters 5 years ago. That it was that unspecified mix of ennui-not feeling-it-ness that made me put it back on the shelf to collect dust; unread and largely forgotten about. And in truth, there is a little something to this assessment. One either has to be in it and fully committed to the reading of a book or not. Largely though, I think it was more a sign of the person I was back then, or the person I had been for many years and the [result] of the lens through which I viewed the world. While I was on the one hand, quite intolerant of anything but the most progressive of views on all “social” issues of the day (and probably still am in a theoretical sense) my views have widened and wisened on how to go about tackling and improving upon them. Up until that point, aside from my humble beginnings, which are the subject of this blog post, I had lived in two of the largest and most “progressive” cities in the world: New York City and San Francisco. I’m now 3.5 years into a stint in suburban North Carolina. While it has been trending greatly this way, my perspective has changed.
But this post is meant to be anything but a political statement or revelation of my point of view on the state of the world. We have enough daily protestations of thorny topics on every social media platform known to the “free” world and nobody gives a shit or cares about one more, let alone mine. And if they did care it’s only because they’re waiting to pounce, dissect, disavow, criticize or cancel it anyway. The main reason for my wanting to put fingers to keys and write was because of the tremendous visceral response I had to the recent reading of this book. And when I get inspired to write-which is sadly less and less these days-I obey its whims and do it. If only for the catharsis of it all, the ability the stream of consciousness gives me and allows for the processing of recently acquired knowledge and ideas.
The reason I have so strongly reacted to this book, to be clear, is not because I too am a hillbilly-not that there’s anything wrong with that! But I may as well have been. Because the family structures, lives, neighborhoods and family dynamics that are so honestly and openly described within Hillbilly Elegy are shockingly similar to those experienced in my New England childhood. Family dysfunction is the same no matter your geographic location and its struggles are universal. The commonality discussed throughout is the lower-middle working class, the raised-by-single-parent/raised-by-multiple-relatives family structures, and the poor communities hanging on to the lowest rung of the socio-economic ladder. “Families” that in reality represent the very fringe of what that word actually means to the general public. I found the world that J.D. describes so akin to my own as he talked about the literal village it took to raise him and to credit him with making it “out.” The converging of all kinds of luck and stars aligning to connect him with those people who made the literal difference in whether he lived or died. For both my brother and me, were it not for our kooky curmudgeonly power-house Nana, CRAZY uncle, select teachers (of both general ed. and dance where I was concerned,) boyfriends/girlfriends, the Performing Arts, and the Military, I’m quite certain we would both have wound up some common cautionary tale at the very least, or a tragic statistic in the worst-case scenario.
My brother and I are the epitomai of “beating the odds.” We have taken starkly divergent paths in original vocation and careers but have coincidentally both ended up presently as educators-although I firmly believe my big brother is a far more talented and passionate one than I will ever be. We both have burning ambition and a will to succeed and be happy unlike anyone I’ve ever known, which I know was borne in spite of our upbringing and not because it was modeled for us. It has taken many years of therapy-one way to go to overcome various ACEs (Adverse Childhood Experiences) like the ones Vance talks about in his book but is not the only way-and a myriad of exposures to all this world has to offer that I’ve been fortunate enough to create for myself, that have conspired to bring me to the person I am today. Because of these efforts, I rarely feel the need/want to cry, whine, deeply ponder, or mourn my childhood. One could look at this as success and say I’d moved on and give me a congratulatory pat on the back and say “good for you.” And for the most part, yeah good for me.
And so given this, I’m always awe-struck when something so powerfully, and suddenly, connects me to those painful early memories that I’d long ago locked away in a vault causing me to meet that little girl anew, and cry for her as I’ve never cried before. These are such old tears, dried out tears, why are they coming back, why now, when I’ve supposedly “moved on”? I guess because of the state of the world, in all of our upheavals and experiences over the past 2 years of this never-ending saga that is this pandemic I’ve grown tired of watching kids, like those my brother and I were, be passed by and forgotten about and become perpetual victims of the same bad policies and systems that plague us today. As J.D. Vance rightly states in the book, no government policies can fix these systemic issues. It takes a mythical cocktail of unknown and individually unique ingredients to cobble together stable happy lives, but it also takes people investing in their communities in ways that matter and has the ultimate impact.
But again, I won’t wax on or propose a bunch of potential solutions within this blog entry, for nobody asked me for my opinion. For while I have many potential ideas and opinions-and strong ones at that-it doesn’t really matter if I state them, write about them, or advertise them in the loudest most societally-appropriate, virtue-signaling manner; pleasing the masses with my majority (rarely lately) or dissenting (more often lately) opinions on how we as a nation have behaved these last couple of years. My only goal for today was to write a bit from my own little corner of the world, insignificant in the grand scheme of things but extremely significant to myself and the life I’ve managed to carve out, eke out, claw out as a result of and despite all that I came from.
Coupled with my uncommon success given my upbringing, It’s not lost on me that I’ve landed upon one of the most successful and stable romantic relationships I’ve ever been in, with someone who, while didn’t come from a “broken home,” has a background not so dissimilar than mine, at least socio-economically. Thank you, J.D. Vance, and your heart-wrenching memoir for forcing me to face these incredibly painful memories this week, with new eyes and mind and heart. Maybe I should pick up anew the memoir of my own that I began writing all those years ago. Even though I’m not the successful lawyer, mover and shaker, and influencer that Mr. Vance is becoming, there just might be some room or a burgeoning tiny platform to highlight my own experiences. Ones that might help a future little Debbie, struggling, sad and lonely in some tiny nothing town, foster some hope and the will to change her stars.
Maybe I will. Stay tuned.